
Choosing an engagement ring is one of the most personal decisions a couple will make — and yet, so many people feel pressure to follow outdated rules, trends, or expectations that don’t truly reflect who they are.
On a recent episode of the Now You May Kiss™ podcast, I had the opportunity to sit down with Carter Eve, founder and designer of Carter Eve Jewelry, to explore what it really means to design jewelry with intention, sustainability, and story at the center.
From engagement rings to heirloom transformations, this conversation reminds couples that — just like their wedding ceremony — their jewelry should feel authentic, personal, and deeply meaningful.
A Childhood Spark That Became a Calling
Carter Eve’s journey into fine jewelry began long before formal training or professional titles. Growing up in Connecticut, she was fascinated by gemstones brought home by one of her father’s international colleagues. What felt magical and mysterious as a child soon became a lifelong passion.
That curiosity led Carter to art school, where she explored many creative disciplines before discovering jewelry design. Living above a jewelry store in New York City, she became captivated by the craftsmanship happening behind the scenes — eventually pursuing formal jewelry training, apprenticeships, and advanced degrees.
Carter went on to earn her BFA in Jewelry and Objects from the Savannah College of Art and Design, a Master’s degree in Jewelry and Metalsmithing from the Rhode Island School of Design, and apprenticed under a master goldsmith — a combination of education and hands-on experience that deeply informs her work today.
Why Engagement Rings Should Never Be One-Size-Fits-All
As your Celebrant for LifeTM, I believe that every ceremony should reflect the couple standing in front of me. It is your story, your values, and your vision for the life you’re creating together.
Carter brings that same philosophy into her jewelry design.
There is no single “right” engagement ring. Instead, the right ring is the one that:
- Reflects your personal style
- Fits your lifestyle and daily activities
- Honors your story and values
- Feels like you
Whether that means a simple diamond band, a vintage-inspired heirloom setting, or a bold, celestial cluster of stones, Carter encourages couples to let go of outdated rules — including the infamous “three months’ salary” myth.
We are living in a time where engagement rings can be expressive, creative, sustainable, and deeply personal.
Reimagining Heirloom Jewelry with Heart & Sustainability
One of the most powerful parts of our conversation centered on heirloom jewelry. If you’ve followed me for any amount of time, you KNOW how much I love heirloom jewelry. The reality though is that pieces passed down through generations that may no longer suit modern styles, but they often hold immense sentimental value.
Carter specializes in transforming heirloom pieces by:
- Resetting center stones into new, modern designs
- Melting and reusing gold to create something entirely new
- Repurposing accent stones into clusters, bands, or earrings
This process not only supports sustainability through reuse and recycling, but also preserves the emotional energy, lineage, and memory carried within the original piece.
For many couples, an heirloom engagement or wedding ring becomes a tangible bridge between generations — honoring the past while celebrating the future.
Caring for Engagement Rings & Fine Jewelry
Fine jewelry is designed to be worn — but it also requires care. During our interview, Carter shared practical, real-life advice that couples often don’t hear:
Everyday Jewelry Care Tips
- Remove rings when working out (yoga included), gardening, cleaning, or lifting weights
- Avoid wearing rings while applying lotion or perfume
- Store rings in a consistent, safe place at home
- When in doubt — take it off
Professional Care Matters
- Have engagement rings professionally cleaned and checked every six months
- Regular inspections help prevent loose prongs and lost stones
- Think of ring maintenance like caring for a car — preventative care matters
These simple habits can prevent heartbreaking loss, especially for irreplaceable heirloom pieces.
Why Appraisals & Insurance Are Essential
One of the most important — and often overlooked — topics Carter discusses is insurance.
To insure a ring properly, it must first be appraised. For custom pieces, Carter provides appraisals upon completion. For vintage or estate jewelry, it’s essential to work with an appraiser who specializes in those pieces.
Insurance offers peace of mind — not because couples expect loss, but because life happens. Fires, accidents, theft, and natural disasters can occur, and having coverage allows couples the ability to recreate or restore something meaningful if the unthinkable happens.
As Carter shared from personal experience in Los Angeles, many clients who lost everything in wildfires were grateful to at least have the ability to rebuild treasured pieces.
Enjoy the Engagement Process
Perhaps Carter’s most heartfelt advice is this: Slow down and enjoy the process.
Engagements are emotional. There is pressure for everything to be perfect. But the ring — like the wedding and the marriage itself — should feel joyful, aligned, and true to who you are.
When couples choose rings that reflect their real lives, personal style, and shared values, the experience becomes not only easier, but far more meaningful.
About Carter Eve Jewelry

Carter Eve Jewelry is a Los Angeles–based fine jewelry studio specializing in handcrafted engagement rings, custom designs, and heirloom transformations. Carter works with recycled gold, ethically sourced gemstones, and conflict-free diamonds to create timeless, wearable pieces designed to honor personal stories and intentional love.
Connect with Carter Eve Jewelry
- Website: https://carterevejewelry.com
- Instagram: @carterevejewelry
- TikTok: @carterevejewelry
- Pinterest, YouTube & Facebook: Carter Eve Jewelry
A Note from Chanelle

As a Wedding Officiant and your Celebrant for Life™, I believe every wedding — and every symbol surrounding it — should reflect the couple it represents. Your engagement and wedding rings, like your vows, are a promise rooted in who you are and who you are becoming together.
Chanelle guides legacy-driven couples as they establish enduring marriages through intentional, artfully crafted ceremony. Request your private consultation.







